Teaching Guide

 

HISTORY FROM BELOW
TEACHING WITH THE NARRATIVE OF AN EX-SLAVE *

James W. Russell, Eastern Connecticut State University

Estaban Montejo began life as a slave in 1860, escaped to spend a number of years in hiding until Abolition came, then returned to the sugar plantations as a free laborer and worked there until going off to fight for Cuban independence in 1895. As slave, cimmarón, sugar worker, and independence fighter, he witnessed from within and participated in the transformation of Cuba's economic, social, and political structure in the decades leading up to this century.

Miguel Barnet, found him in 1963, when he was 103 years old and living in a Cuban nursing home, and recorded his story in Biography of a Runaway Slave. Primarily known as a leading figure in Latin American testimonial fiction, Barnet seeks to give voice to the heretofore voiceless in the historical record--illiterate ex-slaves such as Montejo, for example--who participated in the making but not the telling of history. To accomplish that, he not simply records their voices but also uses the techniques of novel writing to bring them out to their fullest effect--making his works closer to historical novels than oral histories or ethnographies. He used the first rather than third person to narrate Biography of a Runaway Slave and made no attempt made to grammatically or stylistically alter his subject's speech pattern. Indeed, it is that speech pattern which the author tried to capture. It is also the reason why W. Nick Hill, the translator, thought it necessary to bring out a new translation, criticizing a previously published one for flattening out the rich texture of Montejo's narration.

The result is a testament of uncommon interest. Esteban Montejo never achieved fame or fortune in his life. He was never a leader and certainly not an intellectual since he could neither read nor write. But he observed, often very acutely, what went on around him and that is what makes this valuable.

First and foremost it is a testament about Caribbean slavery, one of the three major centers of New World slavery--Brazil and the U.S. south being the other two. In this respect, one of the most intriguing differences between Latin American and U.S. slavery is that the African cultural remnants in language, music, and religion survived much more in the former than the latter and that is clear in Montejo's narrative.

The first major reason for this post slavery cultural difference is that the slave trade ended much earlier in the United States than in Latin America, primarily because the slave population reproduced itself more in the former than the latter and hence new infusions of slaves to replenish the supply were not as needed (see Fogel and Engerman). Slaves who had been brought up on African soil--both physical and cultural--were continuing to come into Latin America as late as the middle of the nineteenth century, long after they had virtually ceased to be coming into the United States, where the slave trade was officially banned in 1808.

Esteban Montejo was in 1963 still able to remember and describe the differences between Congos, Mandingos, Gangas, CarabalÕs, Musungo Congos, and LucumÕs. I am quite sure that it would have been impossible to find an ex-slave in the U.S. in this century who would have been able to do the same simply because those differences were quickly washed away within a generation of arrival on this soil.

This raises the second reason for why African culture survived much longer in Latin than North America. Slaves in the U.S. south appear to have had better physical conditions of living--hence, their greater reproduction--than did Latin American slaves. However, Latin American slaves appear to have enjoyed greater cultural autonomy than did those of the South. A large part of the explanation for this lies with the respective attitudes of the Catholic and Protestant churchs toward the preexisting African religious and other belief-systems of the slave as well as those of the Indian populations. The Catholic priests, like their Protestant counterparts, were horrified at the religious beliefs and customs of Africans and Indians and sought to replace them with their own. But they continued to exist side by side. "Right now," Esteban Montejo observes, "if you up and go to a Catholic church, you see no apples, no rocks, no rooster feathers. But in an African household those are the first things you see. The African is more down to earth." But--and this is the key difference--the Catholic church was much more tolerant than the Protestant churches and willing to compromise in its evangelical mission. It could allow and even partially adopt the indigenous Day of the Dead in Mexico, for example, and in Cuba, "All the religions have become mixed up together in this country," Montejo observes. "The African brought his, the strongest, and the Spaniard also brought his, though not so strong. They all have to be respected. That's my way of doing things."

Initially though, according to Montejo's recollection, Catholicism took hold most among the house slaves because the priests were afraid to enter the prison-like quarters of the field slaves. It was among the more numerous field slaves that African belief systems and other cultural traditions were most strongly carried.

Slave living conditions were particularly harsh in Cuba--long work days in the blazing sun, sleeping at night in prison-like barracoons in which each slave was locked in a suffocating room designed so that he could not communicate with others, and facing the whip for infractions. Twice, as a boy, Montejo tried to escape. The second time he succeeded and lived in hiding in the woods until Abolition came. He then returned to the sugar mills to work, but this time for wages, however meager, and to live in barracoons again, but this time with the locks removed and holes punched in the walls for ventilation.

Abolition, unlike in the rest of Latin America, came in a colonial context in Cuba, as in Puerto Rico. The two Caribbean islands remained as colonial outposts for seven decades after the rest of Spain's Latin American colonies freed themselves through the independence wars of the 1820s. One reason for the difference was that the native-born Cuban upper class, unlike its counterparts in other parts of Latin America, had little interest in independence so long as slavery existed, fearing that an independence revolution would turn into a Haitian-like revolution against slavery which it would be ill equipped to control.

But after Abolition yearnings for independence began to grow stronger, resulting in the 1895-1898 war. Montejo, the ex-slave now sugar worker, was swept up in it and enlisted immediately when it broke out. He recalls that his own understanding of why the war was necessary: "It wasn't fair that so many jobs and so many privileges happened to fall into the hands of the Spaniards alone." But it is not purely nationalist resentment that drove his participation. There was also an initial belief that colonialism was responsible for racial discrimination: "You never saw a black lawyer because they said that blacks were only good for the forest. You never saw a black teacher. It was all for the white Spaniards." He acknowledges though, in the nationalist vein, that "even the white criollos were pushed aside."

Montejo joined up with the Mambises, the fiercest of the independence soldiers. They road into battle bareback and naked wielding machetes with which they literally chopped the heads off of Spanish soldiers.

Once the war--in which over 400,000 died--was over, white Cubans who supported the Spanish side, according to Montejo's bitter observation, ended up with more opportunities than blacks who were on the independence side. Montejo blamed U.S. intervention for being at least partially responsible. During the four years that the U.S. governed the island from 1898 to 1902, it restricted jobs in the police force it was creating to whites. But he was quite aware that the problem of racial discrimination went deeper than the U.S. intervention. "You have to remember," he says, "that the white Cubans were just as much to blame as the Americans because they let themselves be order around in their own country."

The U.S. solidified patterns of racial discrimination in post-colonial Cuba at a time when there may have been other options. A little over two decades earlier the U.S. army occupied the South during Reconstruction. Then it served as a bulwark against--as opposed to promoting--racial discrimination until it withdrew in 1877, allowing the dominant classes to disenfranchise blacks and institute segregation. The U.S. army that later occupied Cuba in a similar post-slavery period though was coming from a country that had chosen not to carry through black freedom but rather to institutionalize segregation and racial discrimination. If two or three decades earlier, the U.S. Army had the opportunity to ensure a social revolution in the South, now it was simply content to solidify the racial status quo ante in Cuba.

This is a book to be read not so much as basic history but rather to complement and round out a basic understanding. It is history as remembered by a very old man and interpreted by a very young man eager to be respectful.

At the same time, it is a book not without faults. In the preface, W. Nick Hill quotes Barnet (from a Post Scriptum to the 1987 Argentine edition) as stating that Montejo "died the 10th of February 1973 at 113 years of age. That same year marks the 100th anniversary of the Abolition of slavery in Cuba and also in the Americas, since Cuba was the last country to overcome this affront to the human condition." Barnet here though committed a double error: the abolition of slavery in Cuba was in 1886, not 1873; and Brazil, not Cuba, was the last country to abolish slavery in the Americas--in 1888. Since the text does not tell the reader exactly when or at what age Montejo escaped and since it is unclear when either he or the author thought that slavery ended, it is impossible to know how long he spent as a runaway.

While it is true that there is not a hard and fast line between fiction and nonfiction--much creative imagination on the part of the authors of historical and testimonial novels must of necessity be employed--it is also true that a reader can always suspect that the author went too far in reconstructing his subject's narrative for literary or other motives. I have no doubt that the U.S. Army during the occupation either promoted or did nothing to stop the development of segregation and discrimination. But was that a salient memory of Montejo or did he serve as a vehicle for the author's concern? I do not know the answer to this except that many readers might find Montejo's comments about the U.S. occupation to be a little too convenient given the political context of intense anti-U.S. sentiment in Cuba in the early 1960s when the book was written.

Regardless of these points though, this is a very valuable book to have. As Dale Graden points out, it is one of the few accounts that exist of Latin American slavery from the point of view of the slaves, whereas several thousand such accounts exist of slavery in the U.S.

Teaching with Biography of a Runaway Slave

Everyone knows that what teachers think of a book and what students think are not necessarily the same thing. Teachers can think that a celebrated book is wonderful and then wonder why students were not similarly impressed. Teachers can also assign a book with one motive in mind and then find that students have entirely different experiences in reading it.

I have assigned Biography once, last fall, in a general introductory class to Latin American studies. The book fit neatly in with two goals that I have for the class. First, for historical background, I teach about colonialism, slavery, capitalism, and feudalism in Latin American history. Thus, Biography provided good reading background for my discussions of colonialism and slavery.

A second major theme in my course is to emphasize the shift from the original Spanish colonial domination of the Spanish-speaking countries to their domination now by the United States. Biography proved to be useful in this respect both because of Montejo's experiences with the War of Independence and his comments on the role of the United States Army during the 1898-1902 occupation in encouraging racial discrimination.

A third major theme in my course concerns revolutions in Latin America, from the independence revolutions to those of Central America in the 1980s. One of the strongest parts of Biography concerns Montejo's experiences in the Cuban War of Independence. This fit well into my course sequence because I then followed it with John Reed's Insurgent Mexico which records his direct observations of several of the campaigns of Pancho Villa in 1913. Part of my motives for assigning this book is that it serves as an antidote to the Hollywood portrayal of Pancho Villa largely as a buffoon. Reed's portrait captures well the outstanding leadership qualities of Villa and allows students to understand why he remains a hero for good reasons to most ordinary Mexicans. At the same time it is not hero worship since Reed also records Villa's limitations as when he asks him what he thinks of socialism and Villa responds that he does not know what it is--this coming from a leader of one of the two major revolutions of the early twentieth century! I also had students read Rebel Radio, which is the wonderful recording of the collective experiences of working with the FMLN's Radio Venceremos during the war in El Salvador. All three thus are accounts from different angles of what it is like to be a participant in revolution.

Most of my students, as revealed on their blue book examinations, got out of the books the human aspects of what it is like to participate in a revolution--the danger, being scared, the bravery, etc. These aspects especially came through in Rebel Radio. In the case of John Reed's book, most of the students came away with a much more accurate and respectful understanding of the charisma of Pancho Villa.

While I never asked students to directly compare the accounts and points of view, one did in a particularly insightful way on two blue book exams. On the second examination, after the students had read Reed's Insurgent Mexico--they had read Biography for the first examination--this student wrote:

Not unlike the biography of a runaway slave, Reed's point-of-view is from the direct inside of the revolution. However this scenario is peculiar in that he is an outsider. In essence it can be said that this book is the point-of-view of an outsider on the inside. To extend the comparison, Biography. . . is the point of view of an insider on the inside.

On the third examination, after reading Rebel Radio, the same student continued:

At the risk of sounding redundant in my tests, the key issue in this book is the point-of-view we get--the insider point-of-view. . .Rebel Radio through a new wrinkle is the insider point-of-view. Runaway Slave gave us one insider's recollections. Insurgent Mexico gave us the outsider on the inside point-of-view and Rebel Radio went a step further and gave us the many insiders' view. Rebel Radio went an extra step in that it gave more life to the revolution, by showing different recollections. . .

Clearly this student had anticipated that the question would call for a comparison and prepared accordingly. The student's writing also indicated to me, that if I had wanted to, I could have pursued further the issue of point-of-view in historical accounts. Barnet attempts to present an unfiltered account of a participant--albeit reconstructed with him acting as an editor to bring it out in all of its authenticity. John Reed in his role as a political journalist was indeed an outsider recording and presenting the daily reality of one part of the Mexican Revolution. Vigil collected all of the stories and anecdotes from the Radio Venceremos staff and then presented them in the first person as if they had been experienced by one person. That is, perhaps to keep with the socialist values of the staff, he created a collective first person.

My teaching experience with Biography of a Runaway Slave has thus been good and I intend to assign it for future classes. However, I do not think that it is a book that stands alone. It must be supplemented by considerable discussion on the part of the instructor in order to fill in the necessary background historical and cultural context as well as to sensitize students to the issue of point-of-view.

REFERENCES

Aching, Gerard. "On the Creation of Unsung National Heroes: Esteban Montejo and Armas's Julian del Casal. Latin American Literary Review, pp. 31-49.

Barnet, Miguel. Biography of a Runaway Slave, translated by W. Nick Hill. Willimantic, CT: Curbstone Press, 1994.

Fogel, R.W. and Engerman, S.L.. Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery. Boston: Little, Brown & Company, 1968.

Graden, Dale. (n.d.) "Miguel Barnet's Biography of a Runaway Slave: Testimonial Literature as History, unpublished.

López Vigil, José Ignacio. Rebel Radio: The Story of El Salvador's Radio Venceremos, translated by Mark Fried. Willimantic, CT: Curbstone Press, 1994.

Reed, John. Insurgent Mexico. New York: International Publishers, 1969.


* Presented at the 1997 Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, Guadalajara, April 17, 1997. Contact: Department of Sociology, Eastern Connecticut State University, Willimantic, CT 06226, U.S.A.; tel. 860-465-4631. E-mail russellj@ecsu.ctstateu.edu


 paperback /ISBN 978-1-880684-18-4 / $13.95 / Ordering Information


 

   Contact Us   Search   Privacy Policy   Site Map
Curbstone Press content © 2001 Curbstone Press. All rights reserved.     

Curbstone Press is supported in part by:   

cialis versus viagra
viagra on line pharmacy
viagra drug prescription
cialis order cheap
buy canada cialis
drug vardenafil
cialis professional next day delivery
drug like viagra
levitra sales
cialis from usa
viagra professional
buy viagra 100mg
viagra pharmacy miami
viagra generic availability india
birth control online pharmacy nexium propecia
cialis discount online
natural cialis
can from propecia who
viagra australia
cialis angioplasty
buy vardenafil us
cheapest cialis on the internet
cheap cialis tablet
canadian viagra store
cialis review
erectile dysfunction therapy
buy tadalafil canada
buy tadalafil in the uk
generic viagra buy
buy drug propecia
buying viagra in poland
purchasing cialis with next day delivery
cialis next day
effect of cialis on women
sildenafil price
buying cialis soft tabs 100 mg
erectile dysfunction viagra
chip cialis
generic for viagra
free cialis
order viagra cheap
order no rx viagra
how to buy tadalafil
viagra generic online
cheepest viagra
canada cialis generic
pfizer viagra canada
cheap viagra
order viagra online uk
what is vardenafil
drug viagra online purchase
no prescription viagra
viagra 100mg england
erectile dysfunction viagra
buy vardenafil cheap online
about levitra
viagra cialis levitra
viagra produced in mexico
no prescription cialis
viagra online canadiain
buy sildenafil in spain
buy cheap generic tadalafil
tadalafil citrate
internet viagra pharmacy
viagra online pharmacy usa
cheapest viagra in uk
generic viagra cheapest online
how levitra works
viagra india
cialisis in canada
get viagra fast
viagra effect
viagra trial
viagra consultation online
compare generic viagra
cialis levitra viagra
cialis free
cheap viagra from pfizer
cheap soft viagra
100mg viagra
where to buy viagra
where to buy viagra in london
cheapest place to buy viagra online
tadalafil buy online
generic pill cialis
find no rx cialis
all about after before propecia
generic viagra for sale on line
buy propecia online prescription
usa cialis
where order viagra
generic viagra
100 mg viagra from canada pharmacy
erectile dysfunction medication
natural viagra online
buy cialis canada
discount pfizer viagra
find cheap viagra
board message propecia
vardenafil dosage
indian viagra
buy viagra in uk
where cialis line
viagra vardenafil comparison
generic viagra sildenafil citrate
cialis tablets for sale
viagra online without prescription
canada propecia
buy viagra online discount
erectile dysfunction smoking
us discount viagra overnight delivery
buy cheap tadalafil online
what better viagra or cialis
viagra online review
which is better viagra or cialis
buy propecia at msn
viagra buy
buy cheap cialis online
discount generic viagra blue pill
cheap cialis pill
where can i buy viagra
buy cod Xenical
cialis pain forum
acheter cialis 20mg
order soma
sciatica from cialis
cialis tadalafil 20mg
u 16361 cialis
generique du cialis
buy viagra germany canadian meds
levitra for women
acheter prozac
cialis compar compar levitra viagra
generic viagra in canada
cialis online bestellen
cialis and fertility
purchase soma online
sacramento buy cialis
Paxil hcl er
cialis refractory period
cialis with benazepril
viagra tablets no prescription
prescription Prozac
Prozac treatment
buy cheap Paxil (Paroxetine) under without rx
buy viagra germany canadian meds
cialis precio
where to buy Xenical by cod
buy cheap Xenical under without rx
medikament Prozac
cheap levitra
levitra effet secondaire
new erectyle drug cialis
cialis doesnt work
online viagra next day delivery
wholesale Prozac cheap
cialis cheap fast
where to buy Prozac by cod
chewable cialis
cialis versus viagra
acomplia generic
cialis blindness
viagra contra cialis
soma no prescription overnight cod delivery
levitra trial
is cialis any good
buy online cialis
does cialis work for everyone
buying viagra online cheap us
online cialis
soft gel Paxil
buy cialis online viagra
us discount viagra overnight delivery
comprare Prozac generico
viagra generic availability india
order cialis online without prescription
Prozac overnight
buy cialis doctor online
find cialis from mexico
cialis generic india
cialis and nueropathy
viagra professionsl
back cialis guarantee money
bayer and levitra
cialis buy now
soma shipped overnight no prescription
cheap viagra from uk
viagra tablet weight
acomplia rimonabant without prescription
discount paxil
buy levitra europe
buy levitra pill
cialis puerto rico
generic for cialis
viagra produced in mexico
buy cialis once daily
cialis no prescription best online pharmacy
phallic symbols in cialis ads
buy Xenical cash on delivery
levitra reviews
10mg call cialis refills
buy viagra uk
Prozac toronto
buy cialis domain
cheap Prozac usa
cialis next day delivery
acomplia zimulti
buy cialis online 32
info levitra
levitra and marijana
buy acomplia without prescription
generic Prozac cost
cialis discount
uk buy Xenical
cialis sans ordonnance
viagra in canada pfizer
india generic cialis
cialis rss feed
30 mg cialis
order lexapro
real viagra online
cialis puerto rico
buy cymbalta
buy cymbalta
cialis generic canada
Price Generic Viagra
Viagra For Sale In Kansas City
Low Cost Viagra
Order Cialis Frankfurt
Pfizer Viagra Price
Buy Viagra In United Kingdom
Cheapest Generic Cialis Online
Womens Viagra
Order Viagra Albuquerque
Pfizer Viagra Price
Buy Cheap Cialis Softtabs
Buy Discount Vardenafil Online Pharmacy
Erectile Dysfunction Information
Buy Viagra Securely Online
50Mg Viagra Softtabs
Buy Cialis Corpus Christi
Buying Online Viagra
Cialis in Chula Vista
Cheap Cialis Virginia Beach
Buy Viagra Mexico
Buy Viagra Akron
Cialis in Frankfurt
Fast Acting Viagra
Cheap Cialis Nashville-Davidson
Order Cheap Viagra
Order Viagra Philadelphia
Generic Viagra Mesa
Lowest Cost Of Viagra
Order Cialis Aurora
Buy Viagra With Discount
Buy Cialis Las Vegas
Cheap Cialis Milwaukee
Best Deals Cialis
Cialis Ordering Overnight Delivery
Generic Viagra Akron
About Propecia Dosage
Buy Cialis Columbus
Dose Of Viagra
Order Cialis Mesa
Lowest Price For Viagra Online
Cheap Cialis Santa Ana
Order Viagra Uk
Real Viagra
Cialis in San Diego
Cheap Cialis Honolulu
Online Pharmacy Hempstead
Buy Levitra Boston
Buy Generic Cialis Uk
Cheap Viagra Without Prescription
Viagra Get
Buy Viagra Hialeah
Buy Cialis San Francisco
Buy Viagra Pittsburgh
Cialis in Washington
Order Cheap Viagra Online
Order Levitra Online
Cialis in Indianapolis
Cost Viagra
Order Viagra Paris
Mail Order Sildenafil
Order Viagra With Mastercard
Order Cialis Sacramento
Generic Viagra Cincinnati
Generic Viagra Pill
Cheap Cialis Jersey City
Low Price For Viagra
Generic Viagra Online
Buy Viagra Cheaply
Order Levitra Online
Order Viagra Hempstead
Cheap Cialis Reno
Where To Buy Sildenafil On Line
Viagra in Portland
Generic Viagra Uk
Buy Viagra With Discount
Viagra Sale Buy
Buy Levitra Melbourne
Low Cost Sildenafil
Generic Viagra Milwaukee
Purchase Viagra
Online Pharmacy Raleigh
Buy Levitra Cheap
Order Cialis St. Petersburg
Sildenafil Cialis
Buy Viagra Wichita
Herbal Remedy For Erectile Dysfunction
Cialis in Frankfurt
Viagra in Durham
Buy Levitra Sacramento
Levitra Cheapest
Viagra Buy Online
Order Viagra Columbus
Order Cialis Oklahoma City
50Mg Viagra
Canada Phizer Viagra
Canadian Online Pharmacy Viagra
Cheap Cialis No Prescription
Generic Viagra By Fedx
Vardenafil Viagra
Generic Viagra Aurora
Viagra No Prescription Canada
Order Cialis Chandler
Cheap Cialis Pharmacy
Generic Viagra Lexington-Fayette
Cialis Tabs
Erectile Viagra
Order Cialis Santa Ana
Cheap Cialis No Rx
International Drug Store Viagra
Buy Viagra Sale
Order Viagra Phoenix
Levitra Viagra
Buy Viagra San Francisco
Online Pharmacy New Orleans
Buy Levitra Phoenix
Generic Viagra Tulsa
Order Cialis No Prescription
Order Viagra Kansas City
Cheap Cialis Milwaukee
Cheap Levitra Online
online pharmacy viagra no prescription
online pharmacy viagra cialis
viagra online without rx
cheap viagra india
viagra zenegra uk
acheter kamagra
buying viagra sample
purchase cialis overnight delivery
acheter kamagra
medicament cialis
trial viagra
propecia nz
viagraviagra onlime sales
discount drugs viagra 100mg
buy cheap levitra for sale
cheap generic viagra 1.00
order proscar
cheap online order viagra
cost of viagra in canada
offshore cialis
name brand cialis
buy cheap online viagra
buy levitra com
cialis class action suit
procurer du cialis
online ritalin viagra paypal
new drug cialis us licensed pharmacies
female cialis source
pfizer how to buy viagra
order viagra online in wisconsin
try levitra for free
zithromax antibiotics online
finax generic propecia drug facts
canada in levitra
discount cialis canada
uk viagra online
discount viagra cialis levitra online
purchase cialis overnight delivery
buy pharmaceutical viagra
getting clomid online
free levitra
avodart vs propecia
buy viagra online au
how to get cialis no prescription
buy pill viagra
viagra online apotheke
compare price best viagra generic
generic levitra 20mg
buy deal herbal viagra viagra
buy cheapest viagra online
cialis south africa
farmaci impotenza
buy viagra pill online
price for generic viagra
buy viagra in hong kong
cheap viagra generic
buy viagra caverta
clomid sale
fertility drug clomid
generic cialis soft tabs 20mg
viagra cailis
cheap viagra nz
viagra supplement
generic cialis pharmacy review
buy cheap p viagra
viagra buy generic
canada pharmacy propecia
cheapest generic viagra and cialis pills
generic propecia finasteride uk
compare viagra price
cialis philippines
viagra cialis canadian pharmacy
valium no prescription buy from india
search viagra viagra find sites buy
free cheap generic cialis pills
viagra cheap usa
acomplia european pharmacy no rx
name brand cialis
cheap generic viagra uk
buy cheapest online place viagra
generic accutane online
buy canada in viagra
order cialis on line
1 order cialis online
buy levitra low price
vigra canada online
no prescription accutane
canada cialis generic
buy online prescription viagra
cialis gt gt information
acheter tadalafil
levitra discount
purchase viagra canada
cheap cialis generic mastercard
cialis and sustanon
generic viagra master card payme
levitra order
sildenafil costo
cialis soft tabs online purchase
female cialis source
cialis levitra viagra
pharmacutical sales levitra
cialis prescription
best price viagra
buy levitra com